Florida Citrus Grower That Killed Millions of Bees With Pesticide Gets $1,500 Fine

Categories: Environmental

photo by Wojsyl via Wikimedia Commons
Flaunt state law by illegally spraying pesticide that destroys millions of bees, threatens a local ecosystem, and costs local beekeepers a quarter of a million bucks? Better think twice! If Florida regulators catch you in the act, you'll have to cough up, uh, about $1,500.

That laughable penalty has environmentalists and beekeepers fuming in Crystal River, where the state found that citrus giant Ben Hill Griffin Inc. broke pesticide laws twice this year yet has levied only one tiny fine.

"Every four days, they were spraying seven or eight different types of chemicals," Crystal River beekeeper Randall Foti tells the Palm Beach Post. "A $1,500 fine is not much of a deterrent."

Worldwide, scientists have been raising the alarm for years about colony collapse disorder, a mysterious phenomenon that's led to mass bee die-offs. Bees are key pollinators for many vital plants, meaning their disappearance has dire consequences for entire ecosystems.

Many have pointed to pesticides as a likely cause, and Foti says he's certain that Ben Hill Griffin's chemicals are to blame for his losses.

On March 19, he asked the state to investigate after aerial pesticide sprayings of the nearby citrus groves killed millions of his bees. Foti later found cans of a pesticide he says the company had been illegally spraying to kill Asian citrus psyllid, an insect pest.

The state looked into it and last week sent Griffin a later saying the company had indeed broken state law with pesticide sprays in February and March.

It's the first time state investigators have linked a mass bee die-off to citrus growers' pesticides, the Post reports, yet regulators levied only a $1,500 fine. (The most they could have demanded from the company is $10,000.)

Ben Hill Griffin hasn't responded to the state's complaint yet and didn't return calls to the Palm Beach Post. Riptide has also left a message with the firm; we'll update this post when we hear back.

That fine pales in comparison to Foti's losses, which he says include $240,000 in honey, not to mention the cost to local ecosystems.

"Fifteen hundred dollars ain't nothin to the grove people," Foti's partner, Barry Hart, says.

Follow Miami New Times on Facebook and Twitter @MiamiNewTimes.

My Voice Nation Help
7 comments
scaupus
scaupus

European bees are not native to North America. No native habitat on this continent is dependent on honey bees. The indigenous Americans called them the "white man's flies." The only species in America that depends on bees is us. Bees pollinate many crops. That's why you see them funny wooden boxes stacked up alongside farm fields. Bees are rented to farmers to pollinate vegetables, etc. Native bees, butterflies and moths aren't really up to the job of handling huge acreages of mono-cultures. There aren't enough of them, and some of them are rather picky about where they dip they're proboscises.

So the only environmental concern, is the concern we should have about pesticides on our food; pesticides in our environment; and pesticides killling native critters.

However, as far as having farmer grown food to eat...for that we should worry about bees.

nevenproductions
nevenproductions

Does anyone know if the bee keepers can make up this $240,000 in a civil lawsuit? Is there a precedent for awards this high?

Kane
Kane

Very Sad.

CA_DixieMay
CA_DixieMay

I saw a comment on FB that the Citrus Grower, as part of the so called penalty, should be forced to grow as many bees as estimated they caused to be lost. I'd be ok with their having to raise twice the number!

mikemoskos1
mikemoskos1

I'm sure the beekeeper will pursue the matter in civil court, but he and other beekeepers should refuse to bring bees anywhere near the company's citrus groves. I don't know if they can keep their own bees, or if its a monoculture that needs them to be imported by outside beekeepers. If it is a monoculture, the company will suffer major losses from no pollination. 

Beekeepers have enormous power now; they need to learn to use it.

Now Trending

From the Vault

 

Loading...