Fat Tax, Like California's, Is Too Much

Categories: Fuming Foodie
fuming_foodie 240.jpg
In an effort to force citizens to make healthier choices, a few countries have instituted a "fat tax" or "junk food tax," which requires consumers to shell out more for unhealthy foods. So far, Denmark and Hungary have done so. France has so far restricted its levy to sweetened drinks.

Health advocates are calling for the United States to institute a junk food tax in hopes that it will help curb obesity and cut down on deaths resulting from cardiac arrest.

This could do away with some food trucks and Cuban bakeries.

Right now England is seriously considering enacting a version. Over here, several proponents point to a U.S. study that revealed a 26 percent decline in sales when sugar-sweetened drinks were taxed at a rate of 35 percent.

But a "soda tax", like one being considered in Richmond, California, would not have a huge impact overall. A study by the British Heart Foundation's Health Promotion Research Group, a 20 percent tax on sugary drinks would lower obesity levels by three and a half percent. I'm thinking that is not enough of an impact to justify such a huge tax hike.

Most advocates of a fat or junk food tax in the United States lean towards higher taxation on sugary drinks as opposed to a blanket tax on all junk food. Many say that foods high in fat yet healthy, such as nuts and avocados, might be unfairly caught in the net.

Dr. Walt Willet, chairman of the department of nutrition at Harvard University's School of Public Health, told ABC News, "Some high-fat foods are related to reduced weight gain. A focus on sugar and refined starch is better, but as a first step I favor a focus on sugar-sweetened beverages as the evidence is strongest for this."

Several U.S. surveys indicate that between 37 to 72 percent of Americans would favor of a junk food tax. Not surprisingly, the food industry is against any version of the fat tax, claiming it would lead to the loss of jobs -- adding that it would be unjust and ineffectual.

Miami smokers and ex-smokers know just how effective such a tax can be. When then Gov. Charlie Crist enacted a one dollar tax per pack of cigarettes in 2009, many Miami smokers decided it was time to quit.

I've said before that when people cannot properly govern themselves, I sometimes agree with government interference. But in this case, the ends do not seem to justify the means.

Follow Short Order on Facebook and Twitter @Short_Order.

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help
Martin Black
Martin Black

A soda tax might only marginally lower obesity, but it will greatly lower diabetes.  If it is enough that at a soda machine or fast food restaurant they have to charge more for the non diet drinks, a lot of people will switch to diet.

Ily Goyanes
Ily Goyanes

Hi Martin,

I would tend to agree that sugary drinks such as sodas are a major contributor to diabetes, as I developed adult onset diabetes through an unhealthy consumption of Coke (I didn't eat sweets).

I'm just concerned that the data gathered so far is not revealing enough of an impact to make everyone, including those who just 'make it a treat,' pay a higher tax. As such taxes are enacted elsewhere and more studies are performed, let's see what happens.


Yes, let's get these American soda addicted morons on the right path. Drink water and natural sodas with little sugar which lowers your libido, increases adult onset diabetes. Fuming Foodies politics are somewhat suspect. Methinks she may be a limbaugh lover

Ily Goyanes
Ily Goyanes

Water is really the way to go. Excessive soda consumption does not do anyone any good, even if it is diet soda. I just don't see the results being enough to make everyone pay a higher price, including those who occasionally partake. Not to mention people who only by soda to mix with alcohol or for parties or even bars and restaurants. There really is not enough data yet to judge.

'Limbaugh lover?' You're cute. I base my opinions and my votes on issues and candidates, not ideologies and political parties. 

Now Trending

From the Vault